| The New Centurions | George C. Scott | The Yellow Rolls-Royce | Ingrid Bergman |
| Notorious | Ingrid Bergman | Saratoga Trunk | Gary Cooper |
| The Westerner | Gary Cooper | The Pride of the Yankees | Teresa Wright |
| Shadow of a Doubt | Teresa Wright | Track of the Cat | Robert Mitchum |
| The Night of the Hunter | Robert Mitchum | Undercurrent | Katharine Hepburn |
| Morning Glory | Katharine Hepburn | Song of Love | Robert Walker |
| Strangers on a Train | Robert Walker | Since You Went Away | Monty Woolley |
| Holy Matrimony | Monty Woolley | Arsene Lupin Returns | Virginia Bruce |
| There Goes My Heart | Virginia Bruce | The Mighty Barnum | Adolphe Menjou |
| The Front Page | Adolphe Menjou | Morocco | Marlene Dietrich |
| Desire | Marlene Dietrich | Pittsburgh | John Wayne |
| Sands of Iwo Jima | John Wayne | Operation Pacific | Patricia Neal |
| Bright Leaf | Patricia Neal | Ghost Story | Fred Astaire |
| You Were Never Lovelier | Fred Astaire | Dancing Lady | Joan Crawford |
| When Ladies Meet | Joan Crawford | Grand Hotel | Greta Garbo |
| Queen Christina | Greta Garbo | A Woman of Affairs | Douglas Fairbanks Jr. |
| Sinbad the Sailor | Douglas Fairbanks Jr. | The Prisoner of Zenda | Raymond Massey |
| Abe Lincoln in Illinois | Raymond Massey | Fire Over England | Vivien Leigh |
| A Streetcar Named Desire | Vivien Leigh | Gone with the Wind | Olivia de Havilland |
| Santa Fe Trail | Olivia De Havilland | Not As a Stranger | Mae Clarke |
| Frankenstein | Mae Clarke | I Died a Thousand Times | Shelley Winters |
| Bloody Mama | Shelley Winters | A Thousand and One Nights | Rex Ingram |
| The Green Pastures | Rex Ingram | Hurry Sundown | Michael Caine |
| Sleuth | Michael Caine | Woman Times Seven | Alan Arkin |
| The Seven Per Cent Solution | Alan Arkin | The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause | Ann-Margret |
| 52 Pick-Up | Ann-Margret | The Pleasure Seekers | Gene Tierney |
| Leave Her to Heaven | Gene Tierney | The Left Hand of God | Lee J. Cobb |
| On the Waterfront | Lee J. Cobb | How the West Was Won | Debbie Reynolds |
| Singin' in the Rain | Debbie Reynolds |