| Hang 'Em High | Clint Eastwood | Two Mules for Sister Sara | Shirley MacLaine |
| Two Loves | Shirley MacLaine | What a Way to Go! | Paul Newman |
| Sometimes a Great Notion | Paul Newman | The Towering Inferno | Steve McQueen |
| Nevada Smith | Steve McQueen | Baby the Rain Must Fall | Lee Remick |
| Experiment in Terror | Lee Remick | A Face in the Crowd | Walter Matthau |
| The Bad News Bears | Walter Matthau | Cactus Flower | Ingrid Bergman |
| Intermezzo | Ingrid Bergman | Murder on the Orient Express | Lauren Bacall |
| The Big Sleep | Lauren Bacall | Written on the Wind | Robert Stack |
| The Last Voyage | Robert Stack | House of Bamboo | Robert Ryan |
| Men in War | Robert Ryan | The Professionals | Woody Strode |
| Sergeant Rutledge | Woody Strode | Once upon a Time in the West | Henry Fonda |
| The Return of Frank James | Henry Fonda | Spencer's Mountain | Maureen O'Hara |
| The Quiet Man | Maureen O'Hara | Against All Flags | Errol Flynn |
| The Adventures of Robin Hood | Errol Flynn | Edge of Darkness | Ann Sheridan |
| It All Came True | Ann Sheridan | Dodge City | Olivia de Havilland |
| A Midsummer Night's Dream | Olivia de Havilland | Captain Blood | Basil Rathbone |
| Tower of London | Basil Rathbone | Romeo and Juliet | Norma Shearer |
| The Divorcee | Norma Shearer | He Who Gets Slapped | John Gilbert |
| The Big Parade | John Gilbert | The Captain Hates the Sea | Victor McLaglen |
| Broadway Limited | Victor McLaglen | The Princess and the Pirate | Bob Hope |
| The Ghost Breakers | Bob Hope | The Iron Petticoat | Katharine Hepburn |
| Little Women | Katharine Hepburn | The Lion in Winter | Peter O'Toole |
| Lawrence of Arabia | Peter O'Toole | Zulu Dawn | John Mills |
| Scott of the Antarctic | John Mills | Hamlet | Julie Christie |
| Darling | Julie Christie | Shampoo | Warren Beatty |
| Reds | Warren Beatty | The Only Game in Town | Elizabeth Taylor |
| Cat on a Hot Tin Roof | Elizabeth Taylor | Little Women | Margaret O'Brien |
| Our Vines Have Tender Grapes | Margaret O'Brien | Thousands Cheer | Kathryn Grayson |
| Kiss Me Kate | Kathryn Grayson | That Midnight Kiss | Ethel Barrymore |
| The Red Danube | Ethel Barrymore | The Secret of Convict Lake | Gene Tierney |
| Leave Her to Heaven | Gene Tierney | Advise & Consent | Walter Pidgeon |
| How Green Was My Valley | Walter Pidgeon | The Hot Heiress | Thelma Todd |
| Horse Feathers | Thelma Todd | | |